Explain why is diamond so hard compared to other gemstones?

In short (click here for detailed version)

The diamond is so hard because it is composed of carbon atoms tightly bonded by covalent bonds, giving it an extremely strong and resistant crystalline structure.

Explain why is diamond so hard compared to other gemstones?
In detail, for those interested!

Dense and robust covalent bonds

Diamond is composed solely of carbon atoms bonded to each other by extremely strong covalent bonds. In these covalent bonds, atoms share their electrons very tightly, forming a kind of rigid and hyper-resistant atomic mesh. This compact configuration makes the structure nearly unbreakable, giving it exceptional hardness. To separate these atoms, one would have to break these very strong bonds, which requires a tremendous amount of energy—this is why diamond can scratch practically everything. Other gemstones have bond types that are much less robust than this, hence their comparative fragility when confronted with diamond.

Very regular crystalline organization

In diamond, each carbon atom is organized in a perfectly regular arrangement called a crystal structure. Imagine a kind of gigantic ultra-ordered network, where all the atoms form a precise geometric pattern — here, a structure called face-centered cubic. This extreme regularity gives diamond incredible stability, as each atom has a specific place that is securely locked in. As a result, moving or disturbing this organization requires enormous energy, hence the diamond's legendary hardness against scratches and impacts. Other crystals that are slightly less strict allow atoms a bit more freedom of movement, making them mechanically more fragile compared to our hyper-organized diamond.

High atomic density

In diamond, the carbon atoms are tightly packed together. This high atomic density means that the atoms are so close that they hardly move, which makes the structure extremely resilient. The denser the atomic network, the harder it is to move or break anything within it. It's somewhat like people in a crowded subway car during rush hour: no one can move easily, so there's less risk of disrupting the structure. This largely explains why diamond is extremely hard, much more so than other gemstones with less densely organized structures.

Extreme training conditions

Diamonds form at depths of 150 to 200 kilometers, under enormous pressures—around 50,000 times the atmospheric pressure at the Earth's surface. Add to that a temperature of about 1,000 to 1,400 degrees Celsius, and you get the perfect conditions to transform carbon into diamond rather than graphite. Without these extreme conditions, carbon would comfortably choose a more stable and much softer form, like graphite, which is just used to make pencil leads! It is precisely because diamonds are created at these depths and under these exceptional constraints that they adopt this incredibly robust and compact structure: not easy to replicate!

Differences with the structures of other gemstones

In other gemstones, such as ruby or sapphire, the atoms are bonded in a less dense and less regular manner than in diamond. Diamond, on the other hand, is made solely of carbon atoms tightly bonded together in a perfect arrangement, which makes it extremely hard. In contrast, gems like emerald or topaz have a less rigid structure, with several types of atoms and weaker bonds between them. These differences in composition and atomic arrangement allow diamond to better resist scratches and impacts: it is simply the boss when it comes to strength.

Did you know?

Good to know

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1

How do we measure the hardness of minerals, including diamond?

The hardness of minerals is generally measured using the Mohs scale, which ranks minerals according to their ability to be scratched by other materials. Diamond has the highest value, which is 10 on this scale, indicating that it can only be scratched by another diamond.

2

Can a diamond be scratched by other materials?

No, only a diamond can scratch another diamond, due to its extreme hardness. That is why the tools used in the industry to work with diamonds are generally also made of diamond.

3

Why is graphite soft while it is also made of carbon like diamond?

Although graphite and diamonds are both composed solely of carbon, the difference lies in their atomic organization: graphite has a layered structure that is loosely connected, allowing for easy slipping, whereas diamond has a dense three-dimensional crystal lattice, which explains its unique hardness.

4

Do synthetic diamonds have the same properties as natural diamonds?

Yes, synthetic diamonds possess almost the same structural, chemical, and physical properties as natural diamonds. Their hardness, brilliance, and durability are virtually identical to those of diamonds mined from the earth.

5

Are there materials harder than diamond?

Some synthetic materials, such as nanocrystalline diamond aggregate or recently created artificial substances, may exhibit a hardness slightly greater than that of natural diamond, thanks to specific structures generated in the laboratory. However, in their natural state, no known material currently surpasses the hardness of diamond.

6

What is the hardest natural material known on Earth?

The diamond is currently the hardest known natural material. Its exceptional hardness primarily comes from its atomic structure, which is composed exclusively of carbon atoms that are strongly bonded to one another by robust and uniform covalent bonds.

Natural Sciences : Geology

No one has answered this quiz yet, be the first!' :-)

Quizz

Question 1/5