Explain why compasses do not work at the poles?

In short (click here for detailed version)

Compasses do not work at the poles because at these locations, the Earth's magnetic field is vertical, which disrupts the functioning of the compass that needs a horizontal field to orient itself.

Explain why compasses do not work at the poles?
In detail, for those interested!

Magnetic field disturbances at the Earth's poles

In the polar regions, the magnetic field behaves somewhat differently. Up there, it becomes particularly irregular, with lots of local disturbances. The Earth has a fluid metallic core in constant motion: these internal currents create a global magnetic field, but at the two ends of the globe, the result is less regular and sometimes downright unstable. The poles are also not fixed; they shift slightly from year to year: this is referred to as the migration of the magnetic poles. These magnetic variations completely confuse the signals sent to your compass, rendering it completely lost and unusable.

Extreme tilt of the magnetic field lines

Near the poles, the lines of the Earth's magnetic field bear no resemblance to those seen in the nice, horizontally aligned illustrations in textbooks. Up there, they literally plunge straight down to the ground, sinking almost vertically into the Earth. This phenomenon, called magnetic inclination, inevitably presents a problem for a magnetic needle that is supposed to pivot horizontally. A traditional compass is designed to follow relatively flat or horizontal magnetic field lines, so when these lines become nearly vertical, it's like asking a regular car to drive calmly up a wall. No wonder the needle completely loses its bearings (pun intended).

Difficulty in locating with the magnetic needle

At the poles, the lines of the Earth's magnetic field plunge almost vertically toward the ground. This is quite bothersome, as a magnetic needle usually aligns horizontally, following the local magnetic field. Up there, this needle really struggles to stabilize since it tries to point downward rather than toward a clear direction of North or South. The result: the compass spins, hesitates, and becomes nearly unusable for indicating your precise direction. With an essentially vertical orientation of the magnetic field, the needle loses all its practical value. It’s like trying to follow an arrow that points straight down beneath your feet; it's hard to derive anything useful for navigation.

Influence of solar phenomena on magnetic poles

The surface of the Sun regularly projects significant amounts of electrically charged particles (solar wind) into space. These particles interact with the Earth's magnetosphere, a sort of magnetic shield that surrounds the planet. At the poles, the lines of the magnetic field tilt sharply toward the ground, making it easier for solar particles to enter our atmosphere. As a result, we get polar auroras, a magnificent light phenomenon that shows that in these areas, the magnetic field is disturbed and unstable. This magnetic instability completely confuses traditional compasses: the needle no longer knows where to point, the direction of north becomes total confusion.

Alternatives to traditional compass use in polar regions

Since the classic compass struggles at the poles, explorers use other methods. GPS has become essential: it works thanks to orbiting satellites, no matter the position on Earth. They also often use inertial navigation systems, or INS, which record every movement to accurately estimate their route. Another simple yet effective trick is visual positioning, such as relying on the position of the stars and the sun with a good old sextant. In modern expeditions, combining these tools generally allows for staying well-oriented despite the unreliable magnetic field.

Did you know?

Good to know

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1

What is the difference between magnetic north and geographic north?

The geographic North refers to the fixed point corresponding to the Earth's axis of rotation. Magnetic North, on the other hand, varies over time and corresponds to the direction that the magnetized needles of compasses naturally point towards. The difference between these two directions is called magnetic declination.

2

What to do if my compass is not working properly in polar regions?

When you are near the poles, the needle of your compass may become inaccurate or unusable due to disturbances in the magnetic field. It is recommended to use other means of navigation, such as Global Positioning Systems (GPS) or traditional techniques of navigation by stars or the sun.

3

Can my GPS entirely replace a compass at the poles?

A GPS receiver can be an excellent alternative near the poles, as it does not rely on magnetic field lines. However, keep in mind that low temperatures and extreme weather disturbances can temporarily affect the functioning of electronic devices. Therefore, it is advisable to have backup instruments and traditional navigation documentation.

4

Does the phenomenon of northern lights affect the functioning of the compass?

The auroras borealis are caused by charged solar particles entering the atmosphere, which interact with the Earth's magnetic field. Although these phenomena generally do not directly disrupt a standard compass, the alterations or magnetic storms associated with the auroras can temporarily induce some disturbances in local magnetic fields, particularly pronounced near the poles.

5

Why does a compass always point to magnetic north?

The needle of a compass is magnetized and naturally reacts to the Earth's magnetic field. It aligns itself along the lines of force of the magnetic field, pointing towards magnetic North rather than geographic North, which is located near the North Pole.

Natural Sciences : Physics

0% of respondents passed this quiz completely!

Quizz

Question 1/5